I didn't know what to say. Most of us got quiet... embarassed in fact. It was a weekly meeting. It was normally a time to share some inspiration and pray. Mostly a rowdy bunch, these guys were Christians. The unusual event was the time when Rob (not his real name) apparently felt considerable anguish. With head down, he was crying real tears. He seemed to feel so unworthy. He confessed to all of us that he masturbated. He felt called to become a pastor. It wasn't long before he left our group. And I never knew what happened to him.
John Piper's comment about masturbation and men in ministry (see quote below) is likely the trigger that reminded me of this story. In any event, Christian leaders have given young men different advice for years. In this post, I look at a sample of comments and offer some thoughts on the subject.
PART 2
“Christians need a
theology of masturbation.” Really?
In the previous post, I considered what Christian thinkers
wrote about female masturbation. In this post, I look at comments focused on
men. And I look at how they use the Bible and reasoning to reach conclusions.
What do we know from research?
According to research summarized by Hyde and Delameter (2017), some 40% of college students recall masturbating before puberty. Data from a 2009 survey indicated 80% of boys reported masturbating by age 17. The data for married men (ages 18 to 49) was similar to that reported in the previous post for women (41 to 61%) reported masturbating in the past 90 days.
What do we know from research?
According to research summarized by Hyde and Delameter (2017), some 40% of college students recall masturbating before puberty. Data from a 2009 survey indicated 80% of boys reported masturbating by age 17. The data for married men (ages 18 to 49) was similar to that reported in the previous post for women (41 to 61%) reported masturbating in the past 90 days.
What the
Bible says about male masturbation:
(The Bible does not address male masturbation unless Judges
3:24 is an indirect reference.)
What do
Christian leaders say about masturbation?
They say a lot of things about sex. And some have opinions about
masturbation.
John
Piper (8 April, 2008) “votes no” in a simple and straightforward commentary.
My understanding of Piper’s reasoning is that male masturbation involves
imagery of a woman, which treats her as a sex object. Masturbation creates
guilt that interferes with obeying God’s will. He acknowledges that most people
masturbate but encourages men not to let this sin keep them from their calling.
Jesse Eubanks and
Josh Hatcher of Relevant
Magazine (2 July 2009) combine the issue of masturbation with lust
and sexual immorality. Amidst the back and forth comments on concerns about
lust and addiction, Jesse wrote: “Masturbation has the potential to be healthy
and even a continuation of worship in our lives. It also has the potential to
destroy life and fellowship with God.” Josh responds with several concerns such
as the effects of masturbation on a married couple’s relationship. In the next
to the last paragraph he writes: “Ultimately, the decision must be made between
the individual and God.”
Driscoll and Driscoll
say a lot. I searched the digital version of their book, Real Marriage, and found 100 matches to the term (several are to
the reference section). They provide statistics consistent with what you will
read most places -- most men masturbate—especially young single men. You will
read about the neurological and biochemical components of the sexual pleasure
involved in the motoric act of masturbation usually coupled with pornographic
imagery. They address the issue of pornography, which is likened to
prostitution.
Finally, they consider the Bible and affirm what was said
above: “The Bible does not forbid masturbation (p. 182).” There is a reference
to possible masturbation in the Song of Songs but again-- no forbidden act.
Additional consideration is given to questions about the helpfulness of masturbation and deciding if it is enslaving. My take is that the bottom
line advice is masturbation become sin when it interferes with God’s design for
sex between a married man and woman. (Read the book for a full context.)
Billy
Graham Evangelistic Association (24 May 2016). In response to a question “…is
masturbation a sin?” The BGEA advised abstaining from masturbation as follows
(see the link for details):
Masturbation is not specifically referred to in the Bible. However, several scriptural principles indicate that it is a practice from which a Christian should abstain. First, it is usually accompanied by the sin of willfully entertaining lustful thoughts and desires which are clearly forbidden by the Lord (Matthew 5:28). The more one dwells on such fantasy, the more likely it is to become a reality in behavior (James 1:14-15). Second, masturbation easily becomes a habit that people become dependent on (Romans 6:12-14). Third, self-directed sex violates God’s creation design for the right use of His good gift of sexuality (Genesis 1:24, 1 Corinthians 7:3-4, 9). Persistent, compulsive masturbation can also be the symptom of deeper psychological or spiritual problems, such as destructive feelings of inadequacy, rejection and loneliness.
James Dobson answered questions about masturbation and many
other issues during his career. In an old letter, he observed that Bible
scholars disagreed on the subject. He asserted that from a medical perspective,
the act is not harmful. He focused on four problematic issues: Guilt, obsession
with masturbation, addiction to pornography, and a habit that can continue into
and affect marriage. Read the short
letter to get the details and context.
Some thoughts…(See also my previous post about women)
1. As in the previous post, Christians won’t find biblical
rules specifically addressing the sex act of masturbation. I suspect this would
pose a problem for those who usually take a biblical rule and apply that rule
in a literal fashion.
2. As with many matters, Christians must use reason if they
wish to create a life principle form biblical texts. As we can see, Christian
thinkers in a position to influence large numbers of people, offer different
opinions about masturbation.
3. I continue to think
that analyzing the morality of masturbation and other topics requires some sort
of rubric. That’s why I still recommend the
six-factor approach (harm, fairness, loyalty, authority, liberty, purity) based
on the work of Jonathan Haidt and his colleagues. This approach promotes
understanding of an issue. It does not answer the question as to whether it is
right or wrong. Most of my comments on masturbation can be found in chapter 7
of A House Divided.
4. Dobson’s comment about obsession indicates a better term
for a problem with sexual behavior that interferes with life functioning than
the term addiction.
5. Concerns about guilt are not uncommon. Guilt can
interfere with well-being thus it must be removed. Those who feel convicted of
sin will find God forgives. Those who feel guilty of violating personal
standards may benefit from self-forgiveness. Those who continue to struggle
with guilt and other distress related to any form of sexuality will be best
served by seeking counseling.
6. The conservative Christian sources I read focus mostly on
boys or men and the problem with pornography. That’s an important concern but
Christians will need to realize that the human sexual response varies from
person to person. Movies considered acceptable by contemporary Christians would
be considered pornographic by Christians a few decades ago. Advertisements for
women’s wear can stimulate a sexual response in men yet not violate any laws of decency in
some countries.
I’ve seen posters about porn designed to scare young Christian
men. An intelligent approach to the pervasiveness of porn requires setting
principled standards of decency. Treating people as sex objects, exploitation
of vulnerable persons, and depictions of rape and harm are common starting
points for setting limits. The problem of deciding what is porn and what is not
porn should not hinder efforts to set moral boundaries.
8. I still think every church and Christian school needs a
sex education program with age-appropriate details. Sex education needs to be a
life-long process. Masturbation is just one topic to include. I cannot imagine how pastors and psychotherapists can do their job if they haven't studied human sexuality.
9. I still don’t see any writers offering opinions about
masturbation and sexual minorities. I wonder if those who identify both as a Christian and as a sexual minority and feel committed to a single life find masturbation to be an
alternative to marriage?
CONCLUSION: Christian Theology, Sex, Masturbation
After considering what others have written, I think a theology of masturbation and even sex might not make sense because there is insufficient context to provide a meaningful framework. I have given some thought to the NEA booklet, Theology of Sex, which I still recommend as a basis for considering views about sex from a conservative Christian perspective.
Although the NEA referred to love in the booklet they do not establish sexuality on a foundation of love, which I consider vital to an integrated Christian-Faith perspective.
Although the NEA referred to love in the booklet they do not establish sexuality on a foundation of love, which I consider vital to an integrated Christian-Faith perspective.
When Jesus summed up the law he gave two commandments pointing us to love of God and others (Matthew 22: 36-40). We know Christians are to be marked by love (John 13:35). Love is the foundation for a theology of sex, more appropriately viewed as a Theology of Human Relationships.
Healthy relationships are characterized by love with attributes of caring and sacrifice. Marital relationships include the gift of sex. And sex is one aspect of love that helps bind couples together. Strong healthy relationships provide a supportive setting for those couples whose sex produces children.
Healthy relationships are characterized by love with attributes of caring and sacrifice. Marital relationships include the gift of sex. And sex is one aspect of love that helps bind couples together. Strong healthy relationships provide a supportive setting for those couples whose sex produces children.
This love-sex connection that brings couples together in a strong relationship ideal for raising children provides not only a basis for a theology of healthy relationships inclusive of sex but it also provides a basis for integrating theology with biopsychology.
As several have pointed out, the Bible does not address the sex act of masturbation.
Unfortunately for sincere young Christians, when Christian leaders offer reasons to consider masturbation as an acceptable or unacceptable alternative to marital sex they disagree. And several writers want to make a point about pornograhpy, which is understandably denounced. No one supports pornography; though no one provided specific guidelines as to what should be off-limits.
Unfortunately for sincere young Christians, when Christian leaders offer reasons to consider masturbation as an acceptable or unacceptable alternative to marital sex they disagree. And several writers want to make a point about pornograhpy, which is understandably denounced. No one supports pornography; though no one provided specific guidelines as to what should be off-limits.
For practices neither mentioned in Scripture nor clearly violating general moral principles prohibiting harm, infidelity, and so forth, Christians are left with the commonly quoted "law of liberty" offered by St. Paul in regard to disagreements over the Sabbath (See Romans 14: 5-6). For those feeling distressed over masturbation or related issues of lust and porn, several writers wisely remind readers about forgiveness.
There are some weak points in the various arguments but I did not consider the critiques worth pursuing in providing any more definitive guidance for Christians. So much has been said.
Previous posts
Perception of Porn Addiction
http://dividedchristians.blogspot.com/2016/04/perceptions-of-porn-addiction.html
http://dividedchristians.blogspot.com/2016/04/perceptions-of-porn-addiction.html
Theology of Masturbation (Women)
http://dividedchristians.blogspot.com/2016/12/theology-of-masturbation.html
Resources
Of course, I want you to buy my book, A House Divided
available from the publisher, Pickwick, and
inexpensively as a Kindle ebook on Amazon.
I refer to the scriptures on masturbation and many other sex topics.
If you are leading a book study group, there's an inexpensive discussion guide for A House Divided on AMAZON.
If you are leading a book study group, there's an inexpensive discussion guide for A House Divided on AMAZON.
I hope it helps with personal study, book study groups, and
related courses at Christian schools and colleges.
There’s also a free website with more information about
sexuality and morality in Christian cultures. https://sites.google.com/site/dividedchristians/
Book ad: Read more about Sexuality and Morality in
A House Divided
A House Divided
References
Hyde, J. & DeLamater, J. (2017). Understanding human sexuality (13th Edition). New York, NY: McGraw Hill. ISBN-13: 9781259544989
Sutton, G. W. (2016). A house divided: Sexuality, morality, and Christian cultures. Eugene, OR: Pickwick. ISBN: 9781498224888
Comments
Post a Comment