God’s Conditional Love

 



Christians Divided About God’s Love

In recent decades, there seems to have been a concerted effort by both conservative and progressive Christians to emphasize God’s love for everyone. However, there are expectations throughout the Bible and continuing to the present suggesting people must do certain things to enter into, and remain in, a loving relationship with God.

This post examines the idea of God’s conditional and unconditional love.


God’s Conditional Love

I was raised in an era when evangelical Christians were keen on getting people saved. I’m sure they still are but the approach seems to have changed. The salvation message was that despite our fine clothes and proverbial Saturday night bath, we were riddled with sins and must repent. We were on the path to eternal damnation in a fiery hell should we die. We were so bad that we could not save ourselves. We needed a savior, which of course is Jesus. If we accepted Jesus as our savior, we would be fine. We sang “Jesus Loves Me” but what really got our attention was the horrors of hell. As the saying goes, bad news sells better than good news.

Many of us were presented with this “good news” in an atmosphere of emotional turmoil. It was a classic good news- bad news situation. Unfortunately, after accepting the good news, we soon learned that there were expectations to be met. There are strings attached if we still wanted to avoid hell. Theology aside, the reality was God had imposed certain conditions on this love relationship.

I am reminded of many Sunday School stories that illustrates the wrath of God for disobedience. Recall that Adam and Eve were cast our of God’s presence and cursed with a thorny and painful life. God’s wrath destroyed most people and animals in the Genesis flood. The horrible killing scenes in the Hebrew Bible made it clear you wanted to be on God’s side. He may be loving but you sure didn’t want to make him mad. And there are those stories and speculations about end times events when people will be separated into those who gain eternal life and those doomed to hell. Once again, it looked like a love-hate situation.

In short, for many Christians, God is like a divine lawmaker and judge who can be merciful and welcoming—even loving— if people repent of wrongdoing but if they don’t, there will be hell to pay. In this view, God’s justice is retributive—wrongdoers are punished.

God’s Unconditional Love

There is another image of God as love. This is the image presented by progressive Christians and those with a similar focus on God’s compassion. In this context, God’s justice is distributive justice—a concern for fairness and right treatment of everyone.

Another point made by writers like Marcus Borg is a matter of emphasis. The oft displayed text of John 3:16 states that “God so loved the world” thus, God did not limit his love to one group of people like the Jews or those going to church. Indeed, it sounds quite universal, which is not something conservative Christians believe.

One wonders how progressive Christians ignore all those horrible histories like those mentioned above. One perspective is a focus on Jesus as the one who perfectly revealed God’s love so that the other images of God were less than perfect.

How Christian’s Write About God’s Love

Conservative

I wanted to see how recent conservatives dealt with the appearance of God’s love as conditional amidst the old imagery impressed on my earlier memories. So, I looked at a couple of conservative sources.

A 2014 Focus on the Family response to the challenge of “unconditional” love is as follows.

As we see it, there’s a sense in which you are seriously misconstruing the import of the term “unconditional love.” When we say that God’s love is “unconditional,” we are asserting that there is nothing we can do to make Him love us either more or less. We don’t earn His love by fulfilling a pre-determined set of conditions. He loves us not because of what we are, but because of who He is – for God is love (1 John 4:8). But this is not to suggest that God doesn’t judge sin or that people won’t have to suffer the consequences of their ill-advised decisions and actions.

Yes, there is such a thing as hell, but nobody will go there because God doesn’t love them. On the contrary, they will go there precisely because they have wilfully chosen to reject His love, freely offered to them in the sacrifice of Jesus Christ. Once they cross that line, there’s nothing more that God can do for them (Hebrews 10:26). But this does not imply that He ceases to love them. He never stops loving even when He is pouring out His wrath, nor does He abandon the soul that turns away from Him. In some way we can’t fully comprehend, He is with us even when we make our bed in hell (Psalm 139:8).

https://www.focusonthefamily.com/family-qa/gods-unconditional-love/

A popular American evangelist of the 20th century was Billy Graham. His organization published a 1973 message, “The love of God,” on May 29, 2018 so, it’s still a current part of their thinking. I included parts of the message showing a contrast between God as a holy judge and God as love.

The Bible teaches that God is a holy God. And because God is righteous and holy, He is also a God of judgment. There is a Judgment Day coming.

But the Bible also teaches that God is a God of love.

The reason God created the human race in the first place was because He loved. He wanted some other creatures in the universe to love. 

But the Bible tells us that God sent His Son to rescue the world in spite of our rebellion, in spite of our sins. God said, “I love you. I love the human race; I want to forgive them of their sins.”

Billy Graham. https://www.billygraham.ca/stories/billy-graham-the-love-of-god/

I think it is fair to say that conservative Christians have not set aside the bad news component of the biblical story. The emphasis is on the good news. God loves you. But you have a choice. And the choice is not pretty. Perhaps this fear of an awful after life accounts for the high percentage of people in the world who identify with a religion or as spiritual.

Progressive

Marcus Borg was a Jesus scholar who has written much about Jesus as the embodiment of God’s love. When writing about God’s love, Borg often talks about God in Jesus showing compassion.

How much does God love the world? So much “that he gave his only Son.” In John, this phrase does not refer to Jesus’s death on the cross as substitutionary atonement for sin, but to the incarnation as a whole. God loves the world so much that God incarnate in Jesus became part of it, vulnerable to it, partaking of it. To love the world means to love the world as God in Jesus loved the world, to give one’s life for it.   Borg in Jesus (pp. 306-307). HarperOne. Kindle Edition.

 

James Burko is one of the writers for progressivechristianity.org. In a post from January 17, 2019, he wrote about “Perfecting Love.” Here’s a quote from his third paragraph. Note that he mentions the problem of the horrible things that have happened.

If God is love, then God is something we do, rather than somebody or something we try to believe in. If God is love, then God is a relationship, and not a Guy in the Sky or some other kind of supernatural entity. If God is love, God is nothing to fear. If God is love, when we really love someone – even of another religion, or of no religion at all – God is in that relationship, blessing it. So these three words wipe away all the theological debates about science and common sense versus religion. These three words sweep away the problem of evil, the perennial conundrum of how an all-powerful God could love people while allowing horrible things to happen to them. If God is love, then God is not in charge of the universe. Love is extremely powerful, but it is not directive. Love does not force anybody to do anything, nor to force anything to do anything to anybody. If God is love, then God is omni-attractive, not omni-potent.

God’s Love — Data

 

I’m a psychologist. I worked as a clinician and university research professor. I’m interested in the psychology of religion. So, in addition to studying the ideas put forth by religious leaders, I want to understand the views of those who attempt to live out their faith. Following are some relevant findings from a few studies.

2006

In September 2006, Baylor university released the results of a survey. A part of the that report was titled “America’s Four Gods.” That section garnered considerable news attention as you can see if you search online.

What the researchers did was analyze the responses to survey items about God’s character and behavior. They found two dimensions: 1. God’s engagement with people and 2. God’s level of anger with sins and punishment. They charted these two dimensions and created four quadrants illustrated on page 28 of their report. On the next page, they describe the “four Gods.” My focus in this post is on Type B: The Benevolent God.

Type B: Benevolent God: Like believers in the Authoritarian God, believers in a Benevolent God tend to think that God is very active in our daily lives. But these individuals are less likely to believe that God is angry and acts in wrathful ways. Instead, the Benevolent God is mainly a force of positive influence in the world and is less willing to condemn or punish individuals.

American Piety in the 21st Century, September 2006 https://www.baylor.edu/content/services/document.php/33304.pdf

 

2012

Two sociologists and a theologian have written about godly love. The results of a survey of Americans were released in 2012. Here’s what they found:

 A majority of Americans (81%) report that they have experienced God’s love, according to a new study. Even more have felt God’s love increasing their compassion for others (83%), showing that for many Americans, the experience of divine love and benevolence are inseparable.” (RNS, December 18).

2016

The Lifeway researchers provided a more in-depth look at Christians’ beliefs related to God’s love in a 2016 survey (lifeway.com, September 27). They did not ask about God’s love in the items I saw, but they did ask about heaven and hell, which are of course the two after-death consequences commonly proclaimed by a wide range of Christian groups. I noticed the differences in a desire for a favourable outcome.

Eighty-four percent of those who hold evangelical beliefs say hell is a place of eternal judgment, where God sends all people who do not personally trust in Jesus Christ. Only 30 percent of Americans who don’t have evangelical beliefs hold that view.

Two-thirds of those with evangelical beliefs (64 percent) say heaven is a place where all people will ultimately be reunited with their loved ones. That’s slightly higher than Americans in general (60 percent).

2018

The 2012 paragraph reporting a high percentage of experience of God’s love is astounding, but we should keep in mind that only about half (56%) of Americans “believe in God as described in the Bible,” (pewresearch.org, April 25, 2018). As relevant to this post, 97% of those who believe in the God of the Bible reported  that God “Loves all people, regardless of their faults.” In general, 93% of Christians believe God is all-loving.

Comments

After seeing the data, I’m inclined to agree with the headline-grabbing title of Rob Bell’s book, Love Wins. I am not saying I agree with Bell’s theology. I am saying that people want to see God as very loving now and in the afterlife. How they handle texts about exclusivity when it comes to blessings in this life or events in the afterlife is obviously quite varied.

https://amzn.to/3rUOmdu

As a psychologist, I am particularly interested in how beliefs and accompanying emotions might drive human behavior. In other words, do beliefs about godly love drive more compassionate responses toward others?  My colleagues and I conducted one study showing a relationship between a group of measures of love of God and spirituality and two dimensions of love of others namely, compassion and forgiveness. Self-reported studies are limited when it comes to actual behavior. My hope is others will continue the search for evidence that those transformed by God’s love are actually carrying out loving responses toward others.

I realize that no psychological study will resolve the question about God’s love as conditional or unconditional. In some sense, those who fuss and fume over the meanings of words, especially sacred concepts, have a reason to do so. In the end, I doubt that anyone who seriously thinks about God would think that love is so boundless that it can embrace any form of evil. I think that spiritual people who are also thinkers will just have to live with that conundrum. Pontificating is not likely to transform lives.

 

References

Borg, M.J. (2006). Jesus: Uncovering the life, teachings, and relevance of a religious revolutionary. New York: HarperCollins.    [AMAZON]        [GOOGLE]

 Sutton, G. W., Jordan, K., & Worthington, E.L., Jr. (2014). Spirituality, hope, compassion, and forgiveness: Contributions of Pentecostal spirituality to godly love. Journal of Psychology and Christianity, 33, 212-226. Academia Link     ResearchGate 

 Sutton, G. W. & Mittelstadt, M. W. (2012). Loving God and loving others: Learning about love from psychological science and Pentecostal perspectives. Journal of Christianity and Psychology, 31, 157-166.  Academia Link   Research Gate Link

Jesus

 Notes

Love. Love is a multidimensional concept. It’s quite vague so it can be easy to define love as conditional or unconditional depending on how you define the concept love. It can get more complicated if you decide that God’s love is different from human love so we are talking about different concepts.

If you are Christian, you likely heard someone talk about Greek words for love (e.g., God’s love as agape). You might be disappointed if you studied Greek (See Mounce). Regardless of what ancient Greeks thought about love, we still need to know how the biblical authors used the words and how people understand God’s love today.

4 Gods. You can find the report containing the “four Gods” on the Baylor website. https://www.baylor.edu/content/services/document.php/33304.pdf  

Two Baylor authors have written a book on the subject, America's Four Gods.

SCOPES and Love. Martin Mittelstadt and I wrote about a multidimensional approach to love some years ago. If interested, see the Sutton & Mittelstadt, 2012 reference.

 

Four Gods


Please check out my website   www.suttong.com

   and see my books on   AMAZON       or  GOOGLE STORE

Also, consider connecting with me on    FACEBOOK   Geoff W. Sutton   

   TWITTER  @Geoff.W.Sutton    

You can read many published articles at no charge:

  Academia   Geoff W Sutton     ResearchGate   Geoffrey W Sutton 

 My ad

A House Divided on AMAZON



 

 

 

Comments